Friday, June 14, 2013

More on Aldus Street:


"Why force the note?  Why imitate?  I'm writing out my thoughts as they come, I have no idea whether they are "literature." I don't care.  I've told you about the lots, Southern Boulevard where the grand shops and movie theatres were, about the haunted house, about the sweet-potato man, and about the kids.  True, the outside was rougher and colder than the inside.  True, I was never as admired and petted and happy in the street as within the sheltering walls of Apartment 5-D.  But I did have a place out on Aldus Street, a society, a rank, and a leader.  I was at home on Aldus Street, as I have never been since.  And when that Halloween night on Aldus Street turned on me, and I was thrust into the exile which remains my true condition, my childhood ended."  

Something about this writing strikes as deeply intimate and true and sad, as though HW were writing straight from the gut onto the page, almost like he's talking directly to you and only you, in a private, intimate conversation with an old and trusted friend.  How does he do that?

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

The Women of IO

So here's a thing I've been kicking around for a while. 

All the women of IO -- yes, even Jan, what we know of her -- are, shall we say, assertive.  Putting aside Momma, Lee, and Sandra, even Bobba is something of a force, if often a passive aggressive one (blue!).

I'm playing with this idea that the Women of Wouk are generational: You have Bobba, old-world frum, never really getting America, nor really wanting to. 
Momma pretended at being a Yankee, but come on.  The pre-Zaideh Goodkind household was not exactly frum, but it was deeply traditional -- a lot of this we owe to Momma.   
True to HW's word, we do not know a lot about Jan, though she did wear big hats.  The home seems to have been "Modern Orthodox"  -- and remember, this is early 70s out of the NY metropolitan area. 
Lee went in the other direction, where her house was kosher but she enjoyed variants of the swine, the abomination, and the mouse.  She was Conservative I suppose?  Hard to say. Her sons, shockingly enough, had no interest in saying kaddish for their father.  Aside for being shkotzim, they were total ingrates and oysvorfs.  I don't know what Lee and Bernie did to deserve this.
 And of course there is Sandra.  Classic rebel of the times (late 60s early 70s, high school-college).  I got a kick out of her, but she wasn't my kid.

So to an extent, mutatis mutandis, we have a bunch of women who were identical.
And David Goodkind accuses Peter Quat of having all the women in his books as identical figures! Anything to be made of this?  Dunno...

Herman Wouk on the Middle East

"To me, Jerusalem is Aldus Street."  And that, my friends, says it all.  Or a lot.  It is why so many Jews who otherwise do not have anything to do with Israel suddenly get so passionate about the whole subject.
I finally got my copy of IO, so here I go again...


Just one of HW's many quotables: "That speech touched heights, never since reached in my hearing, of uncommunicated enthusiasm."

How to understand Mark Hertz?  He is totally apathetic on the Jewish question, Israel, Jewish ritual, etc. yet is regularly miffed by Peter Quat, "our very own Stepin Fetchit Yid." 

Tuesday, January 29, 2013

Herman Wouk on Juicy Steaks

There are a nice handful of comparisons to be made between This is My God and Inside Outside. Certainly Davey Goodkind's views on religion seem to run throughout the former. Gives a lot of material for potential discussion but for now I'm just going to throw out this rather benign point on kashrus:

The impression is widespread that for this reason one cannot get a decent kosher steak. Since we barbecue excellent rare steak in my home - sometimes to the stunned surprise of Jewish guests - I can testify otherwise.

-This is My God

"This is an excellent steak," she observed. "I didn't know kosher food could be this good..."

-Inside Outside


Tuesday, January 15, 2013

Bobbie Webb and Grey Statesmen

Page six gives us our first glimpse of Bobbie Webb [=Betty Wouk?].  A brief allusion, with little sense of what role she will play later.  She is mentioned as much as Sonia Feld, whom we never hear from again. 
How does HW pull this off?  I don't feel like I am being thrown into an alien world with a dizzying array of shadowy characters, but I am already at home in Wouk's world. He does this again and again, and I have no idea how.

According to HW, Nixon and the previous Israeli ambassador, "a blunt ex-general" got along well.  This ex-general's name was, yes, Yitzhak Rabin.  It just so happens that HW dedicated The Will to Live On to YR (and R. Moshe Feinstein -- how's that for range). 

HW then talks about the SecDef, and how he and the SecDef hung out together with 2 chorus girls in Johnny, Drop Your Gun.  I know the play comes up again, but I don't think the SecDef does.
But here's something: SecDef's wife's eyes "looked like glass marbles."  At the end of the book BW's eyes did too.  Coincidence?  Dunno.  (As an aside, Irene, HW's sister to whom IO is dedicated, went blind later in life.  Coincidence? Dunno.) 

...And BC Turns to AD!

All hell has been breaking loose around here, and my peaceful retreat in the Executive Office Building may be coming to a sudden rude end.

And with that, we begin HW's bloated, zany, deeply nostalgic and often grammatically challenged coming of age semi roman a clef.  Not unlike Bobbeh's sour kraut, I can't get enough of it. 

O, the erudition! On page 1 we meet DS Freeeman and his seven volume George Washington, Winston Churchill's comments on the Versailles Treaty, and Hammurabi himself, and not for the last time. 

Saturday, January 12, 2013

Feynman on Honors


If you've read The Language God Talks you know that Herman Wouk felt a certain kinship with Richard Feynman. Both were children of Jewish immigrants growing up in the Bronx in the early part of the 20th century, etc. With that in mind, I get a kick out of the small segment in this video which runs from 1:47 – 2:20.


A fun exercise: Sit back and listen to Feynman for a bit.  Don't pay any attention to the words, just soak in his voice. Then pause the video, close your eyes, and let your mind's ear hear the words "sword, broad".

Monday, January 7, 2013

דור הולך והלכה באה


So my previous comment was in regard to the final exam on Shavuos, I'll pick up there.

I've often said that, before I finally read Rabbi Haym Soloveitchik's masterpiece, Inside Outside was my Rupture and Reconstruction.  What I mean by that is that while reading it, despite the handful of halachik indiscretions I notice, I still feel that I'm reading about characters who are very Jewish.  More Jewish in many ways than I can ever be regardless of what additional stringencies I may accept on myself.  It's this type of "Jewishness" which Rabbi Soloveitchik contrasts to the modern-day type which is measured through adherence to halacha.

So with that as a backdrop I return to the glass breaking moment on Shavuos when Davey Goodkind starts writing in his exam booklet.  There was always this one tiny detail that struck me.  In the opening paragraph of this chapter, the one where he describes a collapsing religious commitment as "a mishmash of pretenses, evasions, embarrassments, and inconsistencies" with which he is fed up (all building up to the infamous "sleeve rolling" confrontation), he mentions that he already rides to football games on the Sabbath.  Presumably he rode to Columbia that very morning.  Yet he hesitates when he looks down at his paper.  He has "never yet written a word on a Sabbath or a religious holiday".  It is the melacha of ksivah on which the end of Yisroelke hinges.

What caught my attention about this is how, for people who grew up in our generation, driving on Shabbos is probably the greater, even greatest, religious taboo.  I think I read one account of someone's trip off the derech (possibly The Hole in the Sheet but I don't remember) where her glass breaking moment was getting into a car on Shabbos.  For our generation that is a much more defining point of no return than writing.  Of course this is all one hundred percent consistent with what he describes in the book.  He mentions how none of them knew anything about a prohibition against electricity until Zeideh arrived.  I believe it's also consistent with halacha actually.  But it's interesting how some halachos can take on far greater societal value than others, and how much these things can change with time.

Look, as long as I live I will NEVER get that kosher hotdog on Pesach thing.  But these attitudes intrigue me.  I'm still interested in trying to understand what a mess Bronx Jewish mores were then.

Name Change

I wanted mine to be from I/O as well.

Where are Finkelstein and Leibowitz?

Just sayin.

Friday, January 4, 2013

Mama, Mama, I Went to Town

When pondering the wonders of I/O, I think about the role of Mama.  For people who have immigrant parents, she is a recognizable force - but what do normal people make of her?  Is she a figure that can be universalized or is she more of an antiquated, charming relic from another era?  Is a lot of the appeal to I/O its particulars, ie, struggling for identity within a conflicting universe of home traditions versus siren song of progressive world, and therefore the novel speaks mostly to the insiders, or can the outsiders appreciate it too?

Thursday, January 3, 2013

Just what is it about "Inside Outside"?

Just what is it about Inside Outside?


"... He started with pleasantries about my novels.  His favorite is Inside, Outside)

HW:  Thank you, Mine too."

- The Lawgiver, pg 99

So what is it?
 
Incorporating multiple perspectives and cogent literary analysis, this blog aims to plumb the depths of "Inside Outside," a novel these bloggers can -- and will -- discuss endlessly.