So my previous comment was in regard to the final exam on
Shavuos, I'll pick up there.
I've often said that, before I finally read Rabbi Haym
Soloveitchik's masterpiece,
Inside Outside was my Rupture and Reconstruction. What I mean by that is that while reading it,
despite the handful of halachik indiscretions I notice, I still feel that I'm reading
about characters who are very Jewish. More Jewish in many ways than I can ever be
regardless of what additional stringencies I may accept on myself. It's this type of "Jewishness"
which Rabbi Soloveitchik contrasts to the modern-day type which is measured through
adherence to halacha.
So with that as a backdrop I return to the glass breaking
moment on Shavuos when Davey Goodkind starts writing in his exam booklet. There was always this one tiny detail that
struck me. In the opening paragraph of this
chapter, the one where he describes a collapsing religious commitment as
"a mishmash of pretenses, evasions, embarrassments, and inconsistencies"
with which he is fed up (all building up to the infamous "sleeve
rolling" confrontation), he mentions that he already rides to football games
on the Sabbath. Presumably he rode to
Columbia that very morning. Yet he
hesitates when he looks down at his paper.
He has "never yet written a word on a Sabbath or a religious
holiday". It is the melacha of
ksivah on which the end of Yisroelke hinges.
What caught my attention about this is how, for people who
grew up in our generation, driving on Shabbos is probably the greater, even
greatest, religious taboo. I think I
read one account of someone's trip off the derech (possibly The Hole in the
Sheet but I don't remember) where her glass breaking moment was getting into a
car on Shabbos. For our generation that
is a much more defining point of no return than writing. Of course this is all one hundred percent consistent
with what he describes in the book. He
mentions how none of them knew anything about a prohibition against electricity
until Zeideh arrived. I believe it's
also consistent with halacha actually.
But it's interesting how some halachos can take on far greater societal
value than others, and how much these things can change with time.
Look, as long as I live I will NEVER get that kosher hotdog
on Pesach thing. But these attitudes
intrigue me. I'm still interested in trying
to understand what a mess Bronx Jewish mores were then.
No comments:
Post a Comment