Wednesday, June 12, 2013

The Women of IO

So here's a thing I've been kicking around for a while. 

All the women of IO -- yes, even Jan, what we know of her -- are, shall we say, assertive.  Putting aside Momma, Lee, and Sandra, even Bobba is something of a force, if often a passive aggressive one (blue!).

I'm playing with this idea that the Women of Wouk are generational: You have Bobba, old-world frum, never really getting America, nor really wanting to. 
Momma pretended at being a Yankee, but come on.  The pre-Zaideh Goodkind household was not exactly frum, but it was deeply traditional -- a lot of this we owe to Momma.   
True to HW's word, we do not know a lot about Jan, though she did wear big hats.  The home seems to have been "Modern Orthodox"  -- and remember, this is early 70s out of the NY metropolitan area. 
Lee went in the other direction, where her house was kosher but she enjoyed variants of the swine, the abomination, and the mouse.  She was Conservative I suppose?  Hard to say. Her sons, shockingly enough, had no interest in saying kaddish for their father.  Aside for being shkotzim, they were total ingrates and oysvorfs.  I don't know what Lee and Bernie did to deserve this.
 And of course there is Sandra.  Classic rebel of the times (late 60s early 70s, high school-college).  I got a kick out of her, but she wasn't my kid.

So to an extent, mutatis mutandis, we have a bunch of women who were identical.
And David Goodkind accuses Peter Quat of having all the women in his books as identical figures! Anything to be made of this?  Dunno...

5 comments:

  1. No way Lee was Conservative. You remember her reaction to Holy Joe's temple. She's a classic case of "the shul I don't daven in is orthodox".

    ReplyDelete
  2. To be clear it would seem your only talking about the women of I, Bobbie Web and other women of the Outside aren't relevant to this discussion..

    ReplyDelete
  3. So how do you undersand Lee?

    Yeah, I'll give you the BW thing.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Any thoughts on how Mrs. Frankenthal fits in to all this?

    ReplyDelete